Resist Now Resist Now Built for Action Take Action

DOJ Threatened Utah's Election Chief With Criminal Prosecution. She Said No.

Resist Now 3 min read
Write or Call Your Rep

The U.S. Department of Justice sent Utah Lt. Gov. Deidre Henderson a letter on July 8, 2026, threatening criminal prosecution for refusing to turn over the state’s private voter registration data to federal officials.

Henderson described the letter on social media as “another love letter” from the Justice Department, “sprinkled throughout with threats of criminal prosecution.” The DOJ had already sued Utah in February 2026 for “failure to produce their full voter registration lists upon request,” alongside lawsuits against other states that similarly refused.

“This is truly bizarre behavior by the federal agency that is supposed to be protecting civil rights.”

Deidre Henderson, Utah Lieutenant Governor, July 8, 2026

The Trump administration framed the voter data demands as an election integrity measure. Henderson disputes that framing on the merits. No documented evidence of widespread voting by ineligible people exists in Utah or nationally, and Henderson has said the U.S. Constitution expressly reserves to states the right to control the “times, places and manner of elections,” including voter data.

States that have pushed back cite both state privacy law and federal statutes that restrict disclosure of personal voter information. Complying with the DOJ demand could expose state officials to liability under those laws. Refusing now exposes them to federal prosecution threats.

Henderson made the same constitutional argument on camera. She appeared on the PBS series “Breaking the Deadlock” on July 8, 2026, the same day she received the DOJ letter. In the episode, a hypothetical scenario asked panelists what they would do if a fictional president pressured them to hand over voter files. Henderson’s answer tracked her real-world position exactly.

Arizona Secretary of State Adrian Fontes received a similar DOJ letter and publicly called it “intimidation.” The coordinated pressure campaign against state election officials signals that the DOJ intends to escalate, not back down.

State election officials who comply risk violating privacy laws. Those who refuse now face criminal prosecution threats from the federal government. There is no neutral option.

What You Can Do Now

  1. Call the DOJ’s public comment line at (202) 353-1555 and tell them to withdraw criminal prosecution threats against state election officials. The DOJ’s own mandate is to protect civil rights, not to criminalize officials who enforce state privacy law.

  2. Call your U.S. senators at (202) 224-3121 and ask them to demand a Senate Judiciary Committee hearing on the DOJ’s voter data campaign. Judiciary members have subpoena power and can compel the DOJ to explain the legal basis for these threats. Hearings create a public record.

  3. Contact Utah’s senators directly. Sen. Mike Lee can be reached at (202) 224-5444 and Sen. John Curtis at (202) 224-5251. Ask them to publicly defend Henderson and introduce legislation clarifying that states cannot face federal prosecution for complying with state voter privacy law.

  4. Find your own state’s election official at nass.org/find-your-secretary-of-state and ask where your state stands on the DOJ voter data demand. At least a dozen states have refused. Yours may be next on the DOJ’s list.

Sources

Utah News Dispatch: Utah Lt. Gov. Henderson Receives DOJ Letter Threatening Criminal Prosecution

PBS: Breaking the Deadlock Episode “How to Fix an Election” Featuring Henderson

U.S. Department of Justice: DOJ Sues Utah and Other States Over Voter Registration Lists, February 2026

National Association of Secretaries of State: Find Your Secretary of State

Arizona Mirror: Arizona Secretary Fontes Calls DOJ Voter Data Letter Intimidation

Write Your Rep ↓